Energy Bill
About these Parliamentary proceedings
Reference
747 cc423-480GC Session
2013-14Legislative stage
Committee stageChamber / Committee
House of Lords Grand CommitteeRelated items
Wednesday, 5 June 2013
Bills
House of Lords
Proceeding contributions
Moved by
Lord Jenkin of Roding
53BA: Clause 23, page 15, line 25, at end insert—
<...My Lords, one of the themes running through our debates on the Bill has been the need to ensure t...
Show all contributions (102)
My Lords, I am extremely grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Jenkin of Roding, for tabling his amend...
My Lords, I am at a wee bit of a loss here. My understanding was that markets operate on the basi...
I remind the noble Lord of some of the figures that I gave at Second Reading. I have been provide...
If this plant were to become necessary, the price would rise—but the “if” involved in the “were” ...
I had not intended to intervene on this point, but I would like to make a similar point to the no...
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords for this short debate, and I thank my noble friend Lord Jenkin ...
Should the situation be even more dire than my noble friend Lord Jenkin suggested, presumably the...
My Lords, I referred to that in my speaking notes. We are keen not to cause an imbalance in compe...
My Lords, I will try to get the passion back into my voice. I was responding to my noble friend L...
My Lords, I began my speech a few minutes ago by saying that I found the Minister’s response very...
My Lords, let me assure my noble friend that mothballed plant will be able to participate in the ...
Yes, but it will not be able to get any money until 2018-19. That is the point of this amendment....
My Lords, let me again assure my noble friend that those who are successful in the capacity aucti...
That is completely new. Does the Minister mean in advance of 2018-19? No, she is being advised fr...
Can I underline what my noble friend has just said? It is extremely difficult to discuss these is...
Does my noble friend want to respond to that?
No, my Lords. I have pointed out that we intend to consult from October on the detail of implemen...
What my noble friend Lord Deben has said merely reinforces the condition that we will have every ...
Moved by
Baroness Worthington
53BB: Clause 23, page 15, line 35, at end insert—
My Lords, this is very much a probing amendment, designed to enable us to discuss again the detai...
My Lords, this is an occasion when the Committee in the House of Lords is particularly valuable t...
I thank the noble Lord for his intervention. I want to clarify that I am not in any way saying th...
My Lords, I could not help but smile when I heard my noble friend Lord Deben start his peroration...
My Lords, I support my noble friend. The amendment only says “prioritise”: it does not say only l...
My Lords, I am extremely grateful to my noble friend for bringing some sanity to this debate. I b...
Before my noble friend sits down, I return to the question that I asked. This is not my amendment...
My Lords, as I said in my speaking notes, I and my officials will be happy to meet noble Lords. T...
My Lords, I am very disappointed. If the noble Baroness cares to read Hansard, she will find that...
I am very aware that the noble Baroness is very passionate about this. I am also very aware that ...
Clearly, we speak to different people. Can you please answer me on whether we can see the Redpoin...
My Lords, I am listening very carefully. I am able to listen and also try to get some responses t...
It would be helpful if they could come from you, would it not? But there we are. I am sorry this ...
My Lords, I think the noble Baroness has completely misunderstood the point I was trying to make....
I apologise for my lack of respect in referring to the noble Baroness, but, as you can see, this ...
My Lords, I do not for a moment suggest that Clause 26 should not be in the Bill. I have adopted ...
My Lords, we endorse the anxieties highlighted by the noble Lord, Lord Jenkin, regarding the use ...
My Lords, I have not intervened before now, on hearing this afternoon’s proceedings, but the refe...
My Lords, I do not intend to delay the Committee unduly on this point, but I echo what has been s...
My Lords, I am extremely grateful to my noble friend Lord Jenkin and the noble Lord, Lord Grantch...
My Lords, I start by saying that what my noble friend has said in response to the amendments abou...
Moved by
Baroness Parminter
55ZB: After Clause 37, insert the following new Clause—
I rise to speak to the group of amendments on the value to the United Kingdom of a European inter...
I would like to ask those who tabled this amendment about the sources of energy that we will be i...
Will my noble friend tell the Committee what is wrong with France? We have an interconnector alre...
We have been told that the dome is now on the power station at Flamanville, so in the not-too-dis...
Is the technology at Flamanville, which my noble friend said is five years late, not the same tec...
It is. Not only is it slow to build, but it is more expensive than some of the other kit that cou...
Perhaps we can get back to the amendment. I support it because connectivity is like an internatio...
My Lords, when I am in a really tedious meeting I sometimes flick to my iPhone if I succumb to th...
My Lords, I support in principle what my noble friend Lady Parminter is proposing in this amendme...
I rise to speak to my Amendments 55AA and 55AD, as part of this group, but perhaps I can come to ...
My Lords, I hope that my noble friend the Minister will look at these amendments as probing amend...
I want to make this point to the noble Lord. We have a department that at the moment cannot provi...
I knew that I should not have raised the noble Lord’s name, because it gave him the opportunity t...
My Lords, my name is also on this amendment and I sat on the same committee, as the noble Earl, L...
My Lords, I am grateful to my noble friends Lady Parminter and Lord Teverson, and the noble Lord,...
I raised a specific point about the extent to which existing capacity, which may get as high as 1...
I apologise. I had a note for the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Chester, but I forgot to a...
The noble Baroness may want to write to me rather than answer now, but if supply gets tight under...
My Lords, it might be wise for me to write in detail to the right reverend Prelate and the Commit...
Given that the Minister is not opposed to the amendment in principle, if the words “12 months” we...
I see that the debate has changed the mind of the noble Lord, Lord O’Neill, but, as with all deba...
I am just an old hand at this game. Ministers who do not have very much to offer Committees somet...
My Lords, as I have said, I read Hansard with great care to see what responses I can give to nobl...
Perhaps I may thank the noble Lord, Lord O’Neill, for the consideration he has given to this side...
I thank all colleagues on both sides of the Committee for their contributions, some of whom have ...
Perhaps this may be a convenient moment for the Committee to adjourn during pleasure until 6.18 p...
Moved by
Baroness Worthington
55ZC: Clause 6, page 5, line 30, at end insert—
“...
My Lords, the amendment would add a new subsection to Clause 6. We now come to the meat of the Bi...
My Lords, we know that strike prices will differ across various technologies but I query whether ...
While I am sympathetic towards this, I have the impression that if the Government do not want thi...
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Worthington, for her amendment and for prompting the d...
Will the Minister answer my question?
I am having an amnesia moment. Will the noble Viscount remind me?
It is in Hansard.
I thank the Minister for her response. I am glad we have restored our equilibrium. We have had a ...
Moved by
Lord Whitty
55ZF: After Clause 6, insert the following new Clause—
“Ex...
My Lords, this amendment would provide for the setting up of an expert committee or advisory grou...
I express my support for the amendment. A number of the utilities are doing something on their ow...
My Lords, I sympathise with a great deal of what the noble Lord, Lord Whitty, said, but I worry t...
My Lords, I support the general thinking behind the amendment, which is different from the amendm...
My Lords, my mind goes back to the group set up last year under the chairmanship of the noble Lor...
Given that the noble Lord, Lord Whitty, wants to formalise this proposal and put it in the Bill, ...
My Lords, I would like to speak briefly in support of the amendment. I see it as a way of advisin...
My Lords, I have great sympathy with what my noble friend has said. The noble Lord, Lord Oxburgh,...
My Lords, I thank the noble Lord, Lord Whitty, for his amendments. Amendments 55ZF and 55ZG would...
I thank the Minister for that detailed reply, and I thank my noble friends Lord O’Neill and Lady ...
Moved by
Lord Berkeley
55A: Clause 9, page 7, line 29, at end insert—
“(4) Regu...
My Lords, I tabled the amendment as a result of a lot of communication from the renewables sector...
My Lords, I know that particularly in the case of offshore wind a Royal Academy of Engineering re...
I should remind your Lordships of my registered interest as a director of the Offshore Renewable ...
I hope that my noble friend will not be lured by the special pleading of the noble Lord, Lord Ber...
My Lords, I quickly intervene because I failed to declare an interest. The noble Baroness, Lady L...
I should reassure the noble Viscount that the wind farm that I inaugurated was offshore, so he is...
My Lords, I am grateful to my noble friend Lord Berkeley for tabling this amendment for no other ...
The amendment moved by the noble Lord, Lord Berkeley, seeks to ensure that renewable technologies...
My Lords, I thank the Minister for her reply and am grateful to all noble Lords who have spoken o...
You commented that you did not like people who said that they did not like windmills; I just fall...
Perhaps I may suggest that if the cap fits, wear it. More seriously, as regards whether the speci...