Civil Liability Bill [HL]
About these Parliamentary proceedings
Reference
791 cc299-342 Session
2017-19Legislative stage
Committee stageChamber / Committee
House of Lords chamberRelated items
Proceeding contributions
Moved by
Lord McKenzie of Luton
6: Clause 1, page 1, line 14, at end insert—
“(...
My Lords, this is a step back from the legal intricacies of the Bill to reflect on a wider issue....
Show all contributions (85)
I thank the noble Lord for his contribution to the debate and I acknowledge the importance of loo...
My Lords, I am grateful to the Minister for a very comprehensive reply. I should say that looking...
Moved by
Lord Sharkey
11: Clause 2, page 2, line 35, leave out from “amount” to end o...
My Lords, the long string of amendments in my name and that of my noble friend Lord Marks has a v...
My Lords, if this amendment is agreed to, Amendments 12 to 22 inclusive cannot be called by reaso...
My Lords, I understand that the clear purpose of Part 1 of the Bill is to discourage false claims...
The amendment tabled by the noble Lords, Lord Sharkey and Lord Marks, seems at least to question ...
My Lords, I congratulate the noble Lords, Lord Sharkey and Lord Marks, for framing a good debate ...
My Lords, the amendments are, as has been said, in my name and that of my noble friend Lord Shark...
Does the noble Lord accept the argument that the quantum of damages is essentially a political de...
Absolutely not. The Judicial College can respond, and be required to respond, to political guidan...
Does the noble Lord accept that if you reduce the amount of damages, it provides something of a d...
Of course I accept that. It is a question of whether the cost in unfairness is worth paying. It i...
My Lords, I concur with the views expressed and proposals made by the noble Lords, Lord Sharkey a...
My Lords, I am grateful for the contributions that have been made. It respectfully appears to me ...
In fact, I was asking the noble and learned Lord, with respect, to justify the quantum, but perha...
With respect, as I say, the quantum is a consequence of the steps we are taking to address the cl...
In that case, perhaps the noble and learned Lord could explain exactly how the tariff was constru...
Yes, I shall come to that. We have had regard to the present level of damages awarded in these ca...
Does the Minister accept that that is not really an explanation? It is simply a statement that th...
With respect, first, I understand that there was not intended to be a change between the impact a...
My Lords, I am very grateful to the Minister for giving way. Perhaps he will confirm to the House...
I think this is a misunderstanding. I was not trying to imply that there was an element of certai...
With respect, a judgment had been made having regard to all the information available as to what ...
I refer my noble and learned friend to his previous comment which, fairly, recognises that all pa...
Everybody readily acknowledges that point but, with respect, you cannot take 650,000 claims and i...
On that point, the Minister will be aware that the business model for insurance companies is to a...
I acknowledge the noble Baroness’s expertise in these areas as a non-executive director of Thomps...
I just wanted to make this point, but because of the noble and learned Lord’s plea I have perhaps...
With respect, as the noble Lord outlined, they are self-perpetuating figures. Therefore, although...
I thank the Minister for the long and comprehensive—and occasionally interrupted—answer. There is...
Can I be clear to the noble Lord? I am not aware of there having been any target saving. As I sou...
The Minister will forgive me if I say that that sounds a bit like the back of a political envelop...
Moved by
Lord Beecham
12: Clause 2, page 2, line 35, leave out “specified” and insert...
My Lords, this amendment and Amendment 29 set an alternative method for recommending a tariff, no...
My Lords, I have Amendment 14 in this group. Much of this ground was covered in the earlier debat...
I just wanted to say one thing. First, I am not sure whether I have declared during Committee tha...
My Lords, I was rather hoping that my noble friend was going to explain the tariff, but that may ...
My Lords, I beg leave to withdraw the amendment.
Moved by
Lord Young of Norwood Green
23: Clause 2, page 3, line 13, at end insert—
My Lords, with the leave of the House I will move this amendment on behalf of my noble friend Lor...
Talking about vulnerable road users, I was reading Tuesday’s edition of Insurance Times, and the ...
My Lords, I support this amendment. I, too, declare an interest as a regular cyclist and a member...
My Lords, we have Amendment 26 in this group. I thank my noble friend Lord Young for stepping in ...
We have not finished the previous group.
I am sorry. I will speak to Amendment 23 only to congratulate my noble friend for stepping into t...
I am obliged to the noble Lord for supporting their proposition rather than their amendment—which...
I welcome what the noble and learned Lord said—I have found it constructive and helpful. Neverthe...
I am perfectly content to meet the noble Lord. As I return to my feet, I am reminded of the regul...
My Lords, once again I thank the Minister for his contribution and will reflect on it when we por...
Moved by
Lord McKenzie of Luton
26: Clause 2, page 3, line 18, at the end insert—
...My Lords, this is a very straightforward amendment. We know that legal costs are unrecoverable in...
My Lords, I have three amendments in this group: Amendments 27, 47 and 52. Amendment 27 seeks a r...
My Lords, I have added my name to Amendments 27, 47 and 52, to which the noble Lord, Lord Marks, ...
My Lords, I am much heartened by what the noble Baroness, Lady Berridge, said because my Amendmen...
When the Minister considers in the round the comments made by other noble Lords, will he undertak...
My Lords, perhaps I may begin with Amendment 26, as put forward by the noble Lord, Lord Beecham, ...
Can the Minister assure me that there will be consultation with the trades unions? Given the case...
Trades unions’ experience is, essentially, filtered through claimant solicitors such as Thompsons...
My Lords, I beg leave to withdraw the amendment.
Moved by
Lord Hodgson of Astley Abbotts
35: Clause 3, page 4, line 5, after “percenta...
My Lords, at this stage in proceedings on the Bill most of the ground has been pretty extensively...
My Lords, I am a little concerned at the degree to which political considerations are supposed ov...
My Lords, I am obliged to my noble friend Lord Hodgson for his amendment. I understand the intent...
I thank my noble and learned friend for that reply. It was not entirely unexpected. I say to the ...
Moved by
Lord Beecham
39: Clause 4, page 4, line 27, after “injury” insert “provided ...
My Lords, the amendments in this group pray in aid, as it were, for the work of MedCo, a body set...
There are other amendments in this group, are there not?
There are indeed, and that was why I wondered at the noble Lord’s reticence. If the noble Lord wi...
I am extraordinarily grateful to the noble and learned Lord for his prompt rising, as it were, fr...
I am obliged to noble Lords. The amendments from the noble Lord, Lord Beecham, would place the re...
I am grateful to the noble and learned Lord for his attempt at reassurance. I will reflect on his...
I quite understand the noble Lord’s concern, and I would be willing to consider any further amend...
I am obliged to the Minister for his invitation, which I will certainly take up. The intention of...
Moved by
Lord McKenzie of Luton
43: Clause 6, page 5, line 31, at end insert—
“...
My Lords, I shall also speak to our other amendments in this group. Amendment 43 requires that re...
My Lords, my own solution to the problem of the promise that the insurance industry has given is ...
I rise briefly to speak to the amendments I have in this group, which refer to a report by the FC...
My Lords, I first speak to Amendment 53 in this group, which deals with passing savings to insure...
My Lords, my name is down to Amendment 46, moved by the noble Earl. I entirely support what was s...
My Lords, clearly these amendments are directed primarily at two areas: first, the review or regu...
My Lords, I thank the Minister for that detailed reply. I am sure that these are matters to which...