Illegal Migration Bill
About these Parliamentary proceedings
Reference
830 cc1742-1826 Session
2022-23Legislative stage
Committee stageChamber / Committee
House of Lords chamberRelated items
Thursday, 27 April 2023
Bills
House of Lords
Proceeding contributions
Moved by
Baroness Ludford
98ZA: Clause 29, page 36, line 13, at end insert “or anothe...
My Lords, I am going to do two things that the Government Chief Whip does not like. First, I am g...
Show all contributions (118)
My Lords, I rise to speak to a number of amendments in this group in my name; namely, Amendments ...
My Lords, I have tabled Amendment 98I on the status of Hong Kongers with British national (overse...
My Lords, I rise to speak in support of the amendments in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Moylan...
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, for tabling Amendment 98I, and I thank Amnest...
My Lords, as noble Lords will see, my name is attached to the amendment from the noble Baroness, ...
My Lords, I will speak to Amendment 95EA in the name of my noble friend Lady Ludford. The amendme...
My Lords, my noble friend Lady Ludford has fully explained our reasons why Clauses 29 to 36 shoul...
My Lords, as we have just heard, Clauses 29 to 36 place a permanent bar on those who fall within ...
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who have spoken in this short debate. It has been particularly ...
I have two short questions. First, how can a child be culpable? The whole point of the Bill, as I...
On the first point, there is no suggestion that these measures impute culpability in the way that...
It may be that I have not quite understood what the noble Lord is saying, but the noble Baroness,...
The answer, which I will turn to in a moment, is that it was considered that greater clarity and ...
Before my noble friend turns to that amendment, I am of course not a lawyer but really quite a si...
I thank my noble friend for that contribution. The position, as he outlined in his speech, is tha...
I was just going to posit to the noble Lord that some of these people having to flee are aged 16 ...
I thank the noble Baroness for raising that. In fact, I was just turning to that very issue.
<...I am very grateful for the Minister’s answer. One of the reasons why I wanted to lay this probing...
My Lords, clearly this needs to be looked into and I hear what the noble Baroness says. After the...
My Lords, our debate on this group has given me a new respect for nationality law, which is at le...
Moved by
Lord Murray of Blidworth
99: Clause 37, page 40, line 30, leave out “or citi...
I warned your Lordships that I would keep popping up this evening, but I am glad to say that the ...
My Lords, I will speak to a number of amendments in my name in this group: Amendments 100, 102, 1...
My Lords, it is an enormous pleasure to follow the noble and learned Lord, Lord Etherton. I decla...
My Lords, I have three amendments in this group: Amendments 101, 110 and 113. Two of these amendm...
My Lords, I will speak briefly to the amendments in this group. In so doing, I refer your Lordshi...
My Lords, I will speak in support of both my noble and learned friends, who sit to my right in th...
My Lords, this has been an interesting, if not bewildering, debate—at least to us non-lawyers. My...
My Lords, this was an interesting debate. I thought I was with lawyers, but then, listening to th...
My Lords, Clause 37 provides for two types of suspensive claims, which have the effect of suspend...
A great deal of research has gone into the risks associated with countries where the law still cr...
The noble Baroness makes an entirely fair point. In those cases, of course, it would be an immine...
I am grateful to the noble Lord for setting out an explanation of the word “compelling”. He used ...
I am grateful for that suggestion from the noble and learned Lord. If I may, I will take a moment...
Before the Minister sits down, there were two specific questions that I raised at the end of what...
I thank the noble and learned Lord for repeating those questions. He is entirely right that I sho...
I am sorry to come back on this, but it is important. The Government must give some guidance to t...
I can only repeat that the Supreme Court decision in HJ (Iran) and the other documents provided b...
My Lords, if two noble and learned Lords and one learned with a small “l” noble Lord—if I may cal...
Yes, I am sorry, it is me again. I am looking forward to the next group, when someone else will b...
My Lords, my noble friend Lady Ludford has clearly explained why Clauses 43 to 51 should not stan...
My Lords, I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Ludford, for explaining this really quite complex area...
My Lords, Clauses 43 to 51 are an essential part of the scheme of the Bill, just like Clause 54 o...
These very short timescales are no doubt part of the deterrent effect which the Government are se...
My Lords, the Government have been working closely with the senior judiciary to ensure that we ha...
I thank the Minister for his responses. I am not really persuaded by his answer on Clause 49: tha...
I will happily write to the noble Baroness. I thought I had covered it when I said that it was cr...
I apologise. I was clearly inattentive as I was trying to look at the other groups that are comin...
Moved by
Lord Murray of Blidworth
115A: After Clause 48, insert the following new Cla...
Moved by
Lord Murray of Blidworth
115B: Clause 51, page 53, line 35, at end insert—
Moved by
Lord Murray of Blidworth
115C: Clause 52, page 53, line 40, after “court” in...
Moved by
Baroness Chakrabarti
116: Clause 52, page 54, line 1, at beginning insert “P...
My Lords, this may be the graveyard shift, but I will do my best to keep the Committee awake for ...
My Lords, I can be relatively brief. I thank the noble Baroness, Lady Chakrabarti, for introducin...
I want to make a brief contribution on Clause 53. We cannot ask the Minister to comment on the im...
My Lords, I shall speak to Amendment 119 and to the overall challenge to Clause 53. To be absolut...
My Lords, the noble Baroness, Lady Chakrabarti, threw down a verbal gauntlet, so let me try to pi...
I beg the noble Lord’s indulgence in standing up and asking him a question. I was piqued by a twe...
I am grateful for that short intervention. I am now not sure whether I am intervening on the nobl...
Before I give way, may I make one other short point? I respectfully suggest that state practice c...
I am grateful to the noble Lord. I draw his attention to the current, as of today, UK Visas and I...
I think that goes back to the point I was making a moment ago. With the greatest respect—I do not...
I am grateful to the noble Lord. It strikes me, in reading this clause, that it proceeds on the b...
On that, I entirely agree: the clause is very carefully drafted. The Government’s position—as I u...
I think we really have to hear from the Minister, frankly. The clause does set out the various ob...
In which case, I will give one final statement before I finish. On this we all agree—the answer t...
If I understand the noble Lord, Lord Wolfson, correctly, he is saying that the solution is not Cl...
My point is that I am supporting Clause 53. It is not inconsistent to say that we will have Claus...
What I am hearing from the noble Lords opposite is that if the Government ignored Rule 39 it woul...
My Lords, I think everybody is really waiting to hear what the Minister has to say about this. It...
My Lords, Clause 52 underpins the suspensive claims and appeals process by prohibiting the courts...
I am grateful to all noble Lords who spoke in this debate—it was not that short—and even more gra...
Moved by
Lord Murray of Blidworth
116A: Clause 52, page 54, line 1, after “court” ins...
Moved by
Lord Murray of Blidworth
117A: Clause 52, page 54, line 7, after second “cou...
Moved by
Lord Murray of Blidworth
119A: Clause 54, page 56, line 7, leave out from “s...
Moved by
The Lord Bishop of Durham
121: Clause 55, page 56, line 21, leave out subsec...
My Lords, in moving Amendment 121 I shall speak to Amendments 122 and 126 in my name. I am gratef...
My Lords, Amendments 124 and 125 are in my name and they have the support of the noble Baroness, ...
My Lords, I will speak to Amendments 123 and 140, following on the points made by the right rever...
My Lords, I thank the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Durham and the noble Baroness, Lady Li...
My Lords, it is a pleasure to follow the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Durham, the noble B...
My Lords, this is a very important group of amendments. I shall not speak particularly to my Amen...
My Lords, as we have heard, these clauses and amendments take us on to the provisions regarding a...
The Minister referred to the figures increasing for disputed children, because the figures in 202...
I do not recognise those statistics, but I will of course look at the Helen Bamber Foundation rep...
Can I just pick up something before the Minister leaves this point? If I understood the noble Bar...
They participate in the particular type of medical scan that is utilised. That is the practice ad...
Whether it is adopted by our European partners or not, Gillick competence is the key UK law that ...
The provisions in the Bill are clear, and, as I say, in due course draft regulations will be prov...
It is quite astonishing to hear a Minister of the Crown say, from what I can understand, that a c...
I fear that we are speaking at cross purposes. I certainly would not compel any child to particip...
The whole point is that they are, in effect, being compelled. This point was made by the interim ...
It is difficult to debate these measures. As I say, in the event that the situation is advanced b...
I am sorry but can the Minister explain how this can be acceptable when subjecting young people—c...
I am not sure that I agree with the allegation that this is unethical because, as the noble Baron...
It may be that the noble Lord, Lord Lilley, has expertise that the Committee is not aware of but ...
As the noble Baroness rightly says, now is not the moment to discuss this hypothetical but it is ...
Has the Minister had discussions with the GMC and social workers, for example?
The noble Baroness now invites me to embark on a discussion that she just said she did not want t...
What is the point of seeking advice if it is then ignored? While I am on my feet, because I was n...
Of course we consider the advice provided by the Age Estimation Science Advisory Committee and th...
The Minister did not allow me to intervene earlier, so will he allow me to intervene now? In what...
We have already canvassed these topics, but there are many ways for a decision-maker to take a re...
I thank all noble Lords for contributing to the debate and for interjecting during the Minister’s...
Moved by
Lord Murray of Blidworth
123A: Clause 55, page 56, line 33, after “court” in...
Moved by
Lord Murray of Blidworth
128: Clause 57, page 58, line 41, at end insert—
Moved by
Baroness Lister of Burtersett
128A: Clause 57, page 59, leave out line 4
...My Lords, Amendment 128A is also being proposed by the JCHR. I thank my noble friend Lord Cashman...
My Lords, I rise—when I get my papers in proper order—to support my noble friend Lady Lister of B...
My Lords, I am sure we are all grateful for his sympathy. I am delighted to be here, but we would...
Well, my Lords, I do not know whether the noble Lord thought my speech about sympathy was repetit...
My Lords, I will speak to the proposition that Clause 57 should not stand part of the Bill. Befor...
My Lords, I will be interested to hear what the Minister has to say to many of the questions rais...
My Lords, I thank all noble Lords who have spoken: the noble Baronesses, Lady Lister and Lady Lud...
My Lords, I am grateful to those who have spoken, especially my noble friend Lord Hacking; he has...