Schools Bill [HL]
About these Parliamentary proceedings
Reference
822 cc1358-1423 Session
2022-23Legislative stage
Committee stageChamber / Committee
House of Lords chamberRelated items
Show all related items (7)
Proceeding contributions
Moved by
Baroness Barran
30: Clause 2, page 3, line 35, leave out subsection (6)
<...My Lords, I turn first to the government amendments in my name. The majority of these represent t...
Show all contributions (108)
I apologise, but I want to intervene on the Minister before she gets too much into her stride. I ...
Of course, we will take that into consideration. I was not aware of the noble Baroness’s concerns...
My Lords, I rise to introduce Amendments 76A and 76B, tabled by my noble friend Lord German, who ...
My Lords, the amendments my noble friend has tabled really show how interconnected all the Bill’s...
My Lords, I speak in place of my colleague, the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Durham, who ...
My Lords, I have a lot of sympathy with the intervention from the Front Bench by my noble friend ...
My Lords, following on from the comments of my friend the noble Lord, Lord Baker, the difficulty ...
My Lords, I will make a couple of observations. First, I strongly agree with the noble Baroness, ...
My Lords, I want to raise a point probably connected to the comments of my noble friend Lord Bake...
My Lords, I declare my interests as a chair of an academy trust and as a trustee of the Education...
My Lords, it is really something for me to say that I agree with most of the noble Lords opposite...
I echo the comments that have been made in support of my earlier intervention. It seems extraordi...
My Lords, I thank your Lordships for your contributions. I confess to being puzzled about the con...
My Lords, with the greatest respect, I say that the Government put those amendments into one grou...
As the noble Lord heard me say, this was agreed through the usual channels where we could have di...
I am grateful; that is helpful. Does the Minister intend to publish any guidance or examples? At ...
I undertake that we will provide guidance—in inverted commas—whether that is formal guidance or s...
Moved by
Lord Addington
31: Clause 3, page 4, line 2, leave out subsection (1)
My Lords, when we come back to this, we come back to our old friend the Delegated Powers and Regu...
My Lords, I rise to speak in place of my noble colleague the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of...
We see that this group concerns the Secretary of State’s power to make regulations for any educat...
My Lords, I am slightly confused about the order of this but I thought it was really important th...
My Lords, I think Amendment 35 allows us to discuss Clause 3 standing part of the Bill, and I wou...
My Lords, Clause 3 stand part was debated on our first day of Committee.
I do not believe that Clause 3 was passed on the first day—
My Lords, Clause 3 was not passed. It is possible for the noble Lord to de-group and discuss Clau...
My Lords, I wonder whether I might assist the noble Lord and the Committee. I just want to make i...
I thought that in fact, with great respect, in the earlier debate we debated Clauses 1 and 4, whi...
My Lords, it may be the Marshalled List that is causing confusion. We have Amendment 35 on the Ma...
My Lords, it might be helpful to point out that my amendment was inspired by the Delegated Powers...
My Lords, I shall now speak to the group of amendments relating to Clause 3, ahead of the questio...
I do not know whether it is the Committee’s problem, but it is my problem, as I do not understand...
My noble friend is right—the thing we should principally be concerned about is improving the educ...
The Minister said at the start of her summing up—and it was about the 20th time she had said it—t...
Tempting as it is to take power into my hands and give the noble Baroness the answer straightaway...
Before the Minister sits down, I just ask a simple question: when?
I must explain to the Committee that I am not able to give a firm date on that today, but as soon...
In the debate last week, I was delighted to commend the wisdom and clarity of the noble Viscount,...
I apologise to the noble Baroness. I do not think there is much I can add beyond what I have alre...
My Lords, really, this is something of a hangover from day one—something I think the noble Barone...
My Lords, I remind the Committee that this Question was debated in the first group of amendments ...
May I speak to this?
I was reminded earlier by the Minister that there was a debate on Clause 3—I remember it very viv...
My Lords, with the greatest respect to the noble Lord—I very much agree with the thrust of what h...
Does the noble Lord wish to continue to discuss Clause 3 stand part?
I would like to. Clauses 1 and 3 are crucial parts of the Bill, and Clause 3 extends the power of...
Since the noble Lord has raised the issue of Clause 3 standing part of the Bill, I wonder whether...
I thank your Lordships. I will keep my remarks extremely brief, because we covered many of the po...
Moved by
Lord Knight of Weymouth
35A: Schedule 1, page 88, line 28, at end insert—
My Lords, Schedule 1 applies the maintained school legislation to academies, as set out in the co...
I am itching to say something, because what I am hearing my noble friend describe is that the bes...
That is where I part company with my noble friend, in that I am relatively comfortable with other...
My Lords, the Clause 28 stand part notice is in my name. Because it is about grammar schools, I t...
My Lords, my name is attached to Amendments 78 and, with my noble friend Lord Storey, Amendment 1...
My Lords, I too have an amendment in this group, but first, in response to the noble Lord, Lord K...
My Lords, I welcome the fact that we are discussing admissions policy. It is not the principal ob...
My Lords, I shall speak against Amendment 35A in the name of the noble Lord, Lord Knight. The ame...
My Lords, I support the thrust of the arguments from the noble Lords who have led this debate. I ...
My Lords, I have a quick comment. I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Hunt, for his history les...
My Lords, can the Minister clarify how special educational needs fits into this picture? I know t...
My Lords, I will briefly enter this debate on Amendment 35A and the question of whether Clause 28...
My Lords, I rise to speak to Amendment 169. I express my gratitude to both Ministers on the Gover...
My Lords, I support the noble Lord, Lord Triesman, in this amendment. I have great respect for pe...
It is pleasure to follow the recent speakers, particularly my noble friend Lord Triesman. That wa...
My Lords, Amendments 35A, 78, 160 and 162 in the names of the noble Lords, Lord Knight, Lord Ship...
We completely accept that the Bill as it stands does not legislate for new grammar schools, but i...
The Bill does not provide for that, and it is not government policy to open further grammar schoo...
My Lords, might I just drop in before the noble Lord, Lord Knight? My noble friend is not right i...
I will happily arrange that conversation. There are two points I would make to my noble friend. T...
My Lords, I am grateful that we have been able to have an hour and 20 minutes to discuss admissio...
I remind noble Lords that if Amendment 35B is agreed to, I cannot call Amendment 36 for reason of...
Moved by
Lord Knight of Weymouth
35B: Schedule 1, page 88, line 33, leave out paragra...
I find myself leading on a whole series of groups: it is slightly challenging, jumping around. Th...
I imagine it will come as no surprise that I support my noble friend Lord Knight. It seems to me ...
My Lords, I have to say that I once had an aunt who was one of the most successful teachers I hav...
My Lords, I was not going to speak in this debate, but I am minded to say just a few words in agr...
My Lords, this is an important question, but, again, I would be looking for the output, not the i...
I support my noble friend. I say to the noble Lords, Lord Knight and Lord Blunkett, that if a tea...
Just to add to that, I think there are—or there used to be—ways for teachers moving from the inde...
It is a real pleasure to follow my noble friend. She is absolutely right: this is about professio...
My Lords, I shall speak to Amendments 35B and 36, which amend Schedule 1. Schedule 1 extends cert...
My Lords, I am grateful again for this half-hour debate and for the Minister’s reply. It is impor...
Moved by
Lord Knight of Weymouth
39A: Clause 5, page 5, line 11, leave out “satisfied...
My Lords, I rise yet again. This substantial group is about intervention and termination powers. ...
My Lords, I remind the Committee that the noble Baroness, Lady Brinton, is taking part remotely. ...
My Lords, I start by apologising to noble Lords who have their names against amendments and claus...
My Lords, I agree with everything that the noble Baroness said; I congratulate her on saying it.<...
My Lords, I appreciate that my noble friend the Minister is in a difficult position; I am sure th...
My Lords, I speak on behalf of my colleague, the right reverend Prelate the Bishop of Durham, and...
My Lords, my degree of fellow feeling for the Minister is growing, as it was when the noble Lord,...
I understand that the noble Lord, Lord Mendelsohn, will not move Amendment 39C. Is that right?
My Lords, it is something running through this debate; there has been discussion on it. I hope we...
The Government are in a bit of trouble here. I have not previously sat through a debate where the...
I start by acknowledging the noble Baroness’s last comments. I will endeavour to come back on the...
May I seek some clarification on that point? Will the payment of trustees and the interim executi...
I will come back to the noble Baroness on that point. I do not have the answers to hand but I wil...
Given that the regulatory review seems to be so significant in the Government’s considerations an...
We plan for the review to be launched in the coming weeks. I cannot give the noble Baroness an ex...
My Lords, the noble Lord, Lord Knight, is right about getting Ofsted into multi-academy trusts. I...
I am grateful for those last comments, and that I do not have to speak for six minutes before I g...
My Lords, I thank the Minister for carefully explaining the Government’s justification for doing ...
Moved by
Baroness Barran
40: Clause 7, page 8, line 7, at end insert—
“(3A) Whe...
My Lords, I beg to move that the House be now resumed—
Before the House is resumed, I draw attention to the clock, which has been stuck for a long time ...