Moved by
Lord Caine
147: After Schedule 4, insert the following new Schedule—
“NO IMMUNITY IN CERTAIN CIRCUMSTANCES
PART 1
SEXUAL OFFENCE, EXISTING CONVICTION OR ONGOING PROSECUTION
Application of this Part
1_ This Part of this Schedule applies if—
(a) a person (P) has requested the ICRIR to grant P immunity from prosecution (the “current request”) under section 18 and conditions A to C are met, but
(b) this Schedule prohibits a grant of immunity for an identified possible offence (see paragraphs 2 and 3).
Prohibition of grant of immunity: sexual offences
2_(1) A grant of immunity for an identified possible offence is prohibited if it is—
(a) a sexual offence, or
(b) an inchoate offence relating to a sexual offence.
(2) For the purposes of this paragraph “sexual offence” includes—
(a) rape;
(b) any offence committed by—
(i) sexual assault,
(ii) sexual activity, or
(iii) causing or inciting another person to engage in sexual activity;
(c) any offence relating to indecent images of children.
(3) For the purposes of this paragraph “inchoate offence relating to a sexual offence” includes an offence of—
(a) attempting to commit a sexual offence;
(b) conspiracy to commit a sexual offence;
(c) incitement to commit a sexual offence;
(d) aiding, abetting, counselling or procuring the commission of a sexual offence.
(4) The Secretary of State may, by regulations, make provision about the meaning of—
(a) “sexual offence”, or
(b) “inchoate offence relating to a sexual offence”;
for the purposes of this Part of this Schedule (including provision specifying offences which are to comprise, or to be included in, that definition).
(5) Regulations under this paragraph are subject to negative procedure.
Prohibition of grant of immunity: conviction or ongoing prosecution
3_(1) A grant of immunity for an identified possible offence is prohibited if—
(a) P has a conviction for the identified possible offence,
(b) P is being prosecuted for the identified possible offence, or
(c) P is being prosecuted for any other offence (whether or not a Troubles-related offence), and the immunity requests panel is satisfied that granting P immunity from prosecution for the identified possible offence would risk having, or would have, a prejudicial effect on that prosecution.
(2) For the purposes of this paragraph—
(a) P is “being prosecuted for” an offence if a public prosecution of P for the offence has begun and is continuing;
(b) a “public prosecution” means any prosecution other than a private prosecution;
(c) a public prosecution of P for an offence “has begun” if a prosecutor has made the decision to prosecute P for that offence;
(d) the circumstances in which a public prosecution of P is to be regarded as continuing include circumstances where the trial which forms part of the prosecution ends without P being convicted or acquitted or any other verdict being given and either—
(i) the period for the prosecution to seek a retrial is continuing (without a retrial having been sought), or
(ii) the prosecution have sought a retrial;
(e) the circumstances in which a public prosecution of P is to be regarded as not continuing include—
(i) circumstances where the trial which forms part of the prosecution ends with P being convicted or acquitted or with another verdict being given, and
(ii) circumstances where the trial ends without P being convicted or acquitted or any other verdict being given and the period for the prosecution to seek a retrial ends without a retrial having been sought.
Grant of immunity prohibited for all identified possible offences
4_(1) If this Schedule prohibits a grant of immunity for all of the identified possible offences, the ICRIR must not grant P immunity from prosecution in relation to the current request.
(2) Accordingly, section 18(1) and (7) to (16) do not apply in relation to the current request.
Grant of immunity prohibited for some identified possible offences
5_(1) This paragraph applies if this Schedule prohibits a grant of immunity for some (but not all) of the identified possible offences.
(2) The immunity requests panel must not decide under section 18(7) that P should be granted immunity from prosecution for—
(a) any identified possible offence for which this Schedule prohibits a grant of immunity, or
(b) a description of offences that includes any identified possible offence for which this Schedule prohibits a grant of immunity.
(3) The ICRIR must not grant P immunity from prosecution for any identified possible offence for which this Schedule prohibits a grant of immunity.
(4) Section 18(7) to (13) have effect subject to this paragraph.
PART 2
NEW REQUEST FOR IMMUNITY AFTER REVOCATION OF PREVIOUS GRANT
6_(1) This paragraph applies where—
(a) under section (Subsequent convictions: revocation of immunity), a court revokes immunity from prosecution granted to a person (P)(the “revoked immunity”),
(b) P requests the ICRIR to grant P immunity from prosecution (the “new request”),
(c) the new request—
(i) is made before the revocation and is not concluded at the time of the revocation, or
(ii) is made after the revocation, and
(d) conditions A to C in section 18 are met in relation to the new request.
(2) When dealing with the new request, the duty of the immunity requests panel to decide (under section 18(7)) what immunity should be granted to P has effect subject to sub-paragraphs (3) and (4).
(3) The panel must not decide that P should be granted immunity from prosecution for any identified possible offence which was also within the scope of the revoked immunity.
(4) When the panel is determining under section 18(9) or (11)(b) a description of offences for which P should be granted immunity from prosecution, the panel must frame the description so that it does not consist of, or include, one or more offences which were also within the scope of the revoked immunity.
(5) If the panel decides in accordance with sub-paragraphs (3) and (4) that there are no offences for which P should be granted immunity—
(a) the panel must decide that P should not be granted immunity from prosecution, and
(b) the ICRIR must not grant P immunity from prosecution (and accordingly section 18(1) does not apply).
(6) For the purposes of this paragraph the new request is “concluded” when the ICRIR gives P written notice of the outcome of the request in accordance with section 18(13)(a).”
Member’s explanatory statement
This amendment deals with offences for which a person cannot be granted immunity from prosecution. The provision about sexual offences is moved here from Clause 19. It contains provision about previous convictions and current prosecutions (replacing Clause 20(1)). It also deals with cases where a person’s immunity from prosecution is revoked under new Clause (Subsequent convictions: revocation of immunity).