UK Parliament / Open data

Enterprise Bill [HL]

I am grateful for those various interventions. There were so many, I am not sure I can respond to them all but I will try.

First, I intended that this general reference to public authorities would include local authorities, for the very precise reason given—that it is more likely that it will be a small business which deals with a local authority. I intended that and if I have not got it right I hope that as we go forward we can look at that further. I am grateful to the noble Lord, Lord Hodgson, for developing his argument with me. I will return to and look at this further because I think it is right.

However, the critical issue here is the words “imbalance of power”. The imbalance of power argument seems to refer as much to the big businesses in the private sector as to a small business dealing either with a local authority or the public sector. Although I accept that the Government are doing a lot here, they should have the confidence to look at this as a way of doing more to show that, just as they make requirements of the public sector, they ensure that their own house is in order and, indeed, setting an example. Together, that would be a much more forceful way forward in what we are trying to do here, which is to deal with the whole issue of late payment.

I see—I am not sure the Government do—the Small Business Commissioner as a one-stop shop. If we start saying to local businesses, “Well, you cannot take issues you have with local authorities to the Small Business Commissioner”, then, although the Small Business Commissioner will be told that he can instruct them to go somewhere else for advice, local businesses will just get frustrated. They will want resolution of their issues. If they are referred around the houses, it will just disillusion them and undermine confidence in the system that we are trying to set up.

I accept the arguments that have been made in the debate. I welcome the support that the amendment has generally received—it was much wider than I expected. Obviously, although I am happy to withdraw the amendment now, I will come back to this matter at a later stage.

About this proceeding contribution

Reference

765 cc127-8GC 

Session

2015-16

Chamber / Committee

House of Lords Grand Committee

Subjects

Back to top