No Confidence in Her Majesty’s Government
About these Parliamentary proceedings
Reference
652 cc1285-1276 Session
2017-19Chamber / Committee
House of Commons chamberRelated items
Monday, 10 December 2018
Parliamentary committees
House of Commons
Proceeding contributions
I beg to move,
That this House has no confidence in Her Majesty’s Government.
Last ni...
Is not the Leader of the Opposition engaging in a piece of shameless political opportunism, putti...
Show all contributions (365)
In 2017, the Prime Minister and her party thought that they could call an election and win it. Th...
If the right hon. Gentleman’s motion is successful this evening, there may be a general election ...
We are a democratic party, and our party will decide what policy we fight the election on. In the...
On a point of order, Mr Speaker. Could you please assist the House, because this is an important ...
The Clerk reminds me that that is not a point of order. My understanding is that there was a pair...
Thank you, Mr Speaker.
Nothing demonstrates the sheer incompetence of this Government quite...
Order. There are courtesies in this place. A Member can seek to intervene, but he or she should n...
I was not shrieking.
Well, whether we say shriek or yell or bellow or shout, it was very noisy, and it was disorderly....
Isn’t the Leader of the Opposition supposed to—
Whether an intervention is taken or not—
No, there is no “all right” about it. The person who has the Floor decides whether to take an int...
Who has confidence in this Government’s ability to negotiate a future trade deal with the EU by D...
In modern British history, when faced with a defeat even a fraction of the size of the titanic an...
I thank my hon. Friend for that intervention. As I made clear, all the precedents are that when a...
As I understand it, the Leader of the Opposition will allow his party to decide whether he will d...
I am sure that the right hon. Gentleman is fully aware of the decision made at my party’s confere...
In this national crisis, will my right hon. Friend confirm whether the Prime Minister has telepho...
I have not had such a call as yet. I have my phone on. [Interruption.]
I think we should pr...
When those cross-party talks start, which of the Scarlet Pimpernels will come? Will it be the Lea...
There has been no offer or communication on all-party talks. All the Prime Minister said was that...
The Leader of the Opposition is making some powerful arguments—not very well, but he is making th...
I thank the right hon. Lady for her intervention, and I look forward to testing opinion at the ba...
My right hon. Friend is right to put on record the concerns about uncertainty in the country, and...
I can absolutely confirm that. We have voted against a no-deal Brexit, and apparently the Busines...
Will my right hon. Friend give way?
I will give way one more time.
I thank my right hon. Friend for giving way. He is absolutely right that, under this Government, ...
I thank my hon. Friend for that intervention and for his work representing his constituency. On t...
Order. No, Mr David Morris, do not yell from a sedentary position like that. If you seek to inter...
Thank you. Mr Speaker.
Will the right hon. Gentleman give way?
No. I am sure we can all unite in condemning racist abuse in any form whatsoever within our socie...
On a point of order, Mr Speaker.
They are looking to Parliament to deliver for them a better and fairer society—
Is the right hon. Gentleman just pausing?
I am pausing because you stood up.
Quite right, absolutely. That is very reasonable and sensible. Thank you. I call Mark Francois, o...
On a point of order, Mr Speaker. Is it not—[Interruption.] Well, give me a go! Is it not often th...
It is commonplace, but it is not, in any sense, obligatory.
Thank you, Mr Speaker.
If the House backs this motion today, I will welcome the wide-rangin...
Last night, the House rejected the deal the Government have negotiated with the European Union. T...
The Prime Minister has lost a quarter of her Cabinet and 117 of her Back Benchers want her gone. ...
The hon. Gentleman might not have noticed that we are debating a vote of no confidence in the Gov...
As someone who was defeated last night by only 230 votes, may I encourage the Prime Minister to K...
My hon. Friend is absolutely right. I shall speak about this later in my speech, but it is over t...
I totally agree with the Prime Minister that a general election would solve nothing—it is merely ...
My hon. Friend is absolutely right that a general election would cause the sort of delay that I h...
I thank the Prime Minister for giving way; unlike some, she is clearly not afraid to debate. It i...
She’s taller than you. [Laughter.]
So is everybody else!
It is possible that the Prime Minister and I will continue to disagre...
I thank my right hon. Friend for his intervention. I note what he said and I am happy to carry on...
In 2017, the Prime Minister went to the country and asked for a mandate; she lost her majority. L...
I said last night that we would be having discussions across the House. There are many different ...
If Members will just be a little patient, I have taken a number of interventions, so I will make ...
Will the Prime Minister give way?
If the hon. Gentleman had listened to what I said—it does help sometimes.
We do not even kn...
On that point, will the Prime Minister give way?
If my hon. Friend would just allow me one moment.
It is barely 18 months since this country...
Does the Prime Minister agree that if the Leader of the Opposition himself wrote on a note exactl...
My hon. Friend is absolutely right, because of course the position that the Leader of the Opposit...
My right hon. Friend the Leader of the Opposition is absolutely right to call for a general elect...
The hon. Gentleman talks about paying for police; of course, we made more money available to poli...
I will make a little more progress, then take some more interventions.
Last night the House...
I tried this with the Prime Minister earlier during Question Time, and I am going to give her one...
The hon. Gentleman will not be surprised to hear that I will give him the same answer as I have j...
I am trying to be helpful to the Prime Minister, believe it or not, but this is pure robotic fant...
I repeat that we will approach the discussions in a constructive spirit. We want to hear from the...
I thank my right hon. Friend for giving way, unlike the Leader of the Opposition. Does she share ...
My hon. Friend puts his point very powerfully indeed. This Parliament voted to ask the British pe...
I will just make a little more progress.
That is what we want to do: deliver on the will of...
On that point—
I will make a little more progress. I have already been generous with interventions.
If tho...
I will give way to the hon. Lady, as she has risen several times.
I thank the Prime Minister for her generosity in giving way. With all due respect to her she has ...
What I am doing is setting out what the British people voted for in the referendum in 2016, and i...
Again, I will just make a little progress.
I know that to serve in Government is a unique p...
Will my hon. Friend give way?
In a moment.
When I became Prime Minister that is what I pledged to do. Yes, to deliver Bre...
I thank the Prime Minister for giving way. The problem is that she seems to be talking as if she ...
What I want to see is what the British people voted for—[Interruption.] No, this is very importan...
If the Father of the House would allow me, I did say to my hon. Friend the Member for Thirsk and ...
I thank the Prime Minister for giving way. She is being criticised for setting and sticking to re...
That is the point that I have been making and repeating. When people voted to leave, they voted f...
I have asked many people throughout this why they voted on one side or the other in the referendu...
My right hon. and learned Friend refers to the fact that, obviously, there were various reasons w...
I will make some progress before I take any further interventions.
I believe that this Gove...
I thank the Prime Minister for allowing me to intervene. Under her leadership, this Government ha...
May I say again that the whole point of this debate today is to determine whether this House has ...
I thank the Prime Minister for giving way. I acknowledge that she wants to paint a good picture o...
The hon. Lady might recall that I made exactly that point when I became Prime Minister—that there...
I appreciate the positive, confident and optimistic picture of the future of the UK painted by th...
Absolutely. Anybody who wants to be Prime Minister should believe in this country and in the tale...
I know that there is so little time to get in all the achievements—[Laughter.] Colleagues may lau...
I thank my hon. Friend, who has set out an area on which this Government have been taking importa...
I am very grateful to the Prime Minister; she is giving way considerably more than the Leader of ...
That is absolutely right. The biggest cash boost to the NHS in its history and a long-term plan t...
If hon. and right hon. Members will forgive me, I am conscious that the time is getting on.
indicated assent.
The right hon. Member for Exeter (Mr Bradshaw) is encouraging me not to take so many intervention...
The Prime Minister is quite right to point out the yawning chasm at the heart of Labour’s policy,...
The purpose of the various discussions that we are going to have is to identify the issues that w...
Will the Prime Minister give way?
I will give way to the hon. Gentleman, and then I am going to make progress so that others can sp...
I am extremely grateful to the Prime Minister for giving way; she has been generous. She has talk...
The hon. Gentleman has been present on many occasions when I have come to listen to and answer qu...
Will the Prime Minister give way?
If my right hon. Friend will bear with me, I will make some progress, as I understand that a sign...
I am grateful to the Prime Minister for being so generous and engaging in a debate. As ever, she ...
What my right hon. Friend experienced last week was appalling. I understand that she has experien...
Will the Prime Minister give way?
I will give way to the right hon. Gentleman, and then I will conclude.
I am grateful to the Prime Minister for giving way. She must recognise that she has built a cage ...
The point I made last night and have repeatedly made today is that I will be talking to people ac...
I was naive to honour a Treasury tradition that went back to Churchill with a text that is pretty...
Order. Stop trying to shout other Members down. Calm yourselves.
The Prime Minister was a member of the party that backed Labour’s spending plans up to late 2009,...
We did see what was happening in terms of the financial crisis and its impact, but the Labour par...
Will the Prime Minister give way?
I am about to conclude, so I will not take any more interventions.
We are living through a ...
It is a pleasure to follow the Prime Minister. Of course, I wish her no ill will and, if she does...
I will give way in a moment. [Interruption.] I say to those on the Government Benches, if they wo...
I thought perhaps the right hon. Gentleman could just inform the House: how many seats in Westmin...
I am grateful to the Prime Minister for that intervention. I say to her that there are 59 seats i...
I think the right hon. Gentleman’s speech is a little eccentric because he seems to think that th...
Let me explain. The hon. Gentleman, in supporting a motion of no confidence against the Prime Min...
The right hon. Gentleman must agree that the Prime Minister is a record setter—record levels of p...
I would say to my hon. Friend, because he is my hon. Friend, that we see a record level of lack o...
Has not the time come for the country to see that the Tory party—not by its words, but by its act...
I am grateful to my dear and honourable Friend for that point because I have to say to this House...
With respect, I know many people want to speak and I have to make progress. I will take intervent...
I first thank the right hon. Gentleman for letting his party give me a seat in this place, but th...
I thank the hon. Gentleman for his intervention. I say to him that the people of Caithness and Su...
I want to make progress; I apologise.
I have talked about Brexit. Let me move on to the rec...
Does my right hon. Friend agree that it is appalling that this Government have slipped out, among...
My hon. Friend is correct to highlight that this Government have been sneaking out those kinds of...
I will give way one more time.
The right hon. Gentleman said earlier that he is worried about economic growth. I share those con...
Oh good grief. I have to say that the hon. Gentleman is mistaken. Over the course of the last yea...
I will give way in a second, but let me just say this. When I look at Scotland in the rear-view m...
I hope that the motion tabled by the Leader of the Opposition is successful this evening. I was r...
There is a very simple answer to that: yes, of course.
I have been generous in taking interventions. I need to move on, because I am only on page 2 of m...
I give way to my hon. Friend the Member for Glasgow South (Stewart Malcolm McDonald). [Interrupti...
Order. The House is over-excited. Although the right hon. Gentleman is well able to look after hi...
They are a curious bunch, Mr Speaker. I ask my right hon. Friend and Members across the House to ...
It’s coming yet for a’ that. [Interruption.] I hear Tory Members from a sedentary position talkin...
As ever, my right hon. Friend is giving a stunning account of the current situation. Does he agre...
I absolutely agree. I reflect on the fact that we in Scotland have a Parliament elected by propor...
I am honoured by the right hon. Gentleman giving way to me, and I am grateful to him. He mentione...
The hon. Gentleman used to sit in the Scottish Parliament. I suggest that if he wants to debate d...
Order. You always have a very amiable disposition, Mr Kerr, but you are becoming a mildly exubera...
Thank you, Mr Speaker. I am proud of the record of investment in public services by my Government...
Order. On account of the level of demand, a five-minute limit on Back-Bench speeches will now app...
When my right hon. Friend the Prime Minister was winding up the debate yesterday evening, she sai...
My hon. Friend is making a compelling case that we should go back to Europe and renegotiate. He k...
No, I am not. Two years ago, we were told by the Prime Minister that nothing was agreed until eve...
In terms of imposing conditions, if we go to no deal we will go immediately to default WTO terms,...
No, I will not engage in trying to respond to all the scaremongering. My hon. Friend is good at t...
No, I am not going to give way anymore. At a sitting of the Exiting the European Union Committee,...
It is a great pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Christchurch (Sir Christopher Chope), who ju...
Order. I am extremely grateful to the right hon. Gentleman and I apologise for interrupting him. ...
A further sentence?
I appreciate it is difficult, but Members do know the minute situation when they stand. They migh...
Mr Speaker, you know I always try to satisfy the demands you place on me, and I will do so now.
I appreciate the right hon. Gentleman’s co-operation.
3.3 pm
It is a great pleasure to speak in this debate.
I have full confidence in the Government an...
I will give way in a minute.
When the Leader of the Opposition stood up at the end and said...
indicated dissent.
The hon. Gentleman is okay, although he asked to intervene.
Will my hon. Friend give way?
It is an honour to give my hon. Friend the opportunity to reflect on the next part of his speech ...
My right hon. Friend is absolutely right. We have a Prime Minister with the experience. We also h...
We have adequate justification for this no-confidence motion in the form of the numbers yesterday...
I will support the Government today. This is absolutely no time for a self-serving general electi...
I rise to support this motion of no confidence because at this critical time in our history I bel...
My hon. Friend makes a telling point. While the Government dither over Brexit, meanwhile back hom...
I agree with my hon. Friend. This Government are paralysed, dealing with their own obsessions, no...
My hon. Friend is, as always, making an informed and detailed speech. Does she agree that it is o...
I entirely agree, and some of the imbalances caused by that Government in the way our unwritten c...
My right hon. Friend the Member for Putney (Justine Greening) hit the nail on the head when she s...
My hon. Friend is absolutely right to say that the first duty of the state is to protect its citi...
I will come on to security in a second.
It is not just Labour Members who feel threatened b...
Will the hon. Gentleman give way?
I need to carry on.
No Prime Minister should be an enemy of our democracy or of our institu...
Will the hon. Gentleman give way?
Order. At the moment, the hon. Gentleman is not giving way.
We are members of NATO, and we believe that an attack on one is an attack on all. We are committe...
Since yesterday evening, I have been struck by how many hon. Members have been assiduous in their...
It is a privilege to follow the right hon. Member for Belfast North (Nigel Dodds).
We gathe...
I will give way when I have finished this point.
We have introduced a national living minim...
My hon. Friend is making a good case for why this should be a vote of no confidence in Her Majest...
My hon. Friend is probably right, but I do not want to be distracted from focusing on the issue a...
Order. This tendency of Members on both sides of the House to refer to other Members by name is q...
Will the real right hon. Member for Islington North please stand up? To channel my inner Leader o...
I rise to support the motion not simply because the Government have made a mess of Brexit, althou...
Order. Before I call the hon. Member for Maidstone and The Weald (Mrs Grant), who has been advise...
I am very confident that a great future awaits the UK after we have left the EU. We are the fifth...
I will be supporting this no-confidence motion for a number of reasons. I could go into any of th...
That point has been covered on a multitude of occasions, today and in previous debates. I am not ...
I am delighted that my right hon. Friend the Leader of the Opposition has tabled and secured this...
The right hon. Gentleman absolutely hits the nail on the head in respect of the Prime Minister. I...
The Prime Minister is in a total state of denial. We are not going to get anywhere unless that ch...
Will the right hon. Gentleman give way?
No, I am not giving way.
Giving the decision back to the people also has the advantage of b...
Thank you, Mr Speaker, for giving me the opportunity to speak in this debate.
Yesterday was...
The hon. Gentleman talks about politics being a game, but all this is more about self-interest. E...
The hon. Gentleman knows my views on a lot of what has gone on, including on the calling of that ...
Does my hon. Friend agree that there is no social mobility in bankruptcy and that it is only if w...
My hon. Friend hits the nail on the head. It is rank hypocrisy that comes out of Opposition Membe...
Does my hon. Friend agree that every Labour Government in history have left the country in bankru...
I totally agree with my hon. Friend. We have just had to sit through a bizarre rant from a Member...
I will not give way again; I have given away enough already.
I really think that we should ...
Believe me, I feel no shame. [Interruption.] Opposition Members can shout at me as much as they w...
I am grateful for the chance to speak in this debate.
The essence of our argument was laid ...
It is a pleasure to follow the right hon. Member for Birmingham, Hodge Hill (Liam Byrne). I do no...
Will the right hon. Lady give way?
Of course I will take the extra minute.
The right hon. Lady talked at the beginning of her speech about fairness. I would suggest that th...
I do not agree with that analysis at all. The problem is that if we do not get the economy of our...
I think it is a pleasure to follow the right hon. Member for Broxtowe (Anna Soubry), although I c...
It is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Crewe and Nantwich (Laura Smith). I rise to make a...
Will the hon. Gentleman confirm—it escapes me—whether the Conservative party manifesto also said,...
Absolutely not. We have the right approach to industrial strategy, the right approach to clean en...
I wish the hon. Member for Plymouth, Moor View (Johnny Mercer) were still in his place, because w...
I will not give way, because loads of people want to speak and I want to be fair to them.
I...
I am a former soldier. During my military career, we were given an aim and an execution to carry ...
Does my hon. Friend share my concern about asking for a second referendum? Why should anyone trus...
I agree, and in my short speech on Monday I made exactly that point. How can any of us go to our ...
How does my hon. Friend interpret what the Prime Minister said last night about reaching out to t...
Nothing would delight me more than if every single MP in the House said, “Let’s get behind the Pr...
It is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for South Dorset (Richard Drax), because his speech sh...
During the remain campaign, the hon. Gentleman and I were on the same side of the debate. I am su...
This is not the afternoon for the hon. Gentleman to lecture me about holding my leadership to acc...
If that is the case, will the right hon. Gentleman explain why so many on his side—173 MPs, I thi...
The hon. Member for Ilford North (Wes Streeting) has just been elevated to the Privy Council. I t...
It has been a long time coming, Mr Speaker.
I say with some humility to the hon. Member for...
It is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Ilford North (Wes Streeting).
It is well doc...
It is an honour to follow the hon. Member for St Austell and Newquay (Steve Double), although I m...
If the result in that referendum were again to leave, would the hon. Lady be willing to respect t...
What I am proposing here is a means for this place to find its way out of the present impasse. At...
I rise to support the Government and to speak against this motion. In doing that, I will talk abo...
If ever there were an advert for why we need a general election and why we have no confidence in ...
In moving this motion of no confidence earlier today, the Leader of the Opposition claimed that i...
I think the Leader of the Opposition has 13 policies on Brexit, not none.
I am grateful to my hon. Friend for clarifying the multiplicity of policies that the Leader of th...
I will give way again in a moment.
I heard the NHS mentioned as well—of course, a vital ins...
It is a pleasure to follow what I will say was a textbook speech from the hon. Member for Croydon...
I can understand the hon. Gentleman’s dilemma. What would be the effect on his area if we were to...
Barrow-in-Furness is a shipyard town, and the programme is woven into our history. More than 9,00...
It is an enormous honour to follow a speech as brave as the one by the hon. Member for Barrow and...
As we appear to be in a political twilight zone, I feel the need to say a few home truths. I have...
I am delighted to follow the hon. Member for Paisley and Renfrewshire South (Mhairi Black); it is...
Just before I call the right hon. Member for Cynon Valley (Ann Clwyd), I should announce that she...
I am going to read a letter from a constituent—a real person—that I received this morning by emai...
A three-minute limit is now to apply.
5.18 pm
This House can have confidence in the Government because they have taken the country from the bri...
There are more children!
Yes, that is 87% of a bigger number—of course it is. It is even better. And that is despite the w...
I thank the hon. Gentleman so much for giving way. I do appreciate it. I know that we are short o...
I hesitate to explain basic mathematics. A rise from 66% to 87% of a bigger number is even more o...
On a point of order, Mr Speaker. Is the term “pillock” considered unparliamentary?
I do not think that that word was used. I think the word was “paleo”. It is rather unfair that th...
Economic security, greater opportunity, sustainable investment in our public services and many ot...
I rise to say that I have no confidence in Her Majesty’s Government. In doing so, I will not addr...
Well, it is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Stalybridge and Hyde (Jonathan Reynolds), al...
It is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Eddisbury (Antoinette Sandbach).
The unsettl...
Even though I respect the comments made by the hon. Member for Kingston upon Hull West and Hessle...
Margaret Thatcher famously quoted Attlee in saying that referendums were the instruments of “dema...
I am obviously not terribly delighted that we are having a vote of confidence in the Conservative...
Record spending in the NHS.
Record debt is what we would have. The hon. Lady’s party is offering this country and my voters—m...
I am very happy to give way and take the extra time.
The hon. Gentleman, perhaps because he is rather younger than me, seems to have forgotten that, w...
And when the hon. Lady’s party left power, we had record debt, a crashed economy and a loss of co...
Order. There is a very unseemly atmosphere, but the hon. Gentleman is at least still smiling, and...
Thank you, Mr Speaker. The truth is that the Labour party left power under an enormous cloud. Eve...
I thank the Leader of the Opposition for tabling this motion of no confidence, which I will suppo...
It is a pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Bradford West (Naz Shah).
I would argue that...
Last night’s defeat was an extraordinary humiliation for the Prime Minister. If ever there were a...
As ever, it is a huge pleasure to follow the hon. Member for Brighton, Pavilion (Caroline Lucas)....
What people and businesses in Basingstoke tell me is that they want certainty. How can they get c...
Certainty is all. I will be speaking about that in the Adjournment debate later—Jaguar Land Rover...
The provocation for this debate was the unprecedented defeat of the central plank of the Governme...
This debate should be one of two halves. First, it is right that the Opposition challenge the Gov...
I will vote for the motion, not just because of the Government’s failure on Brexit but because of...
I wonder whether the right hon. Gentleman knows how many Opposition Front Benchers have resigned ...
I was actually going to mention the hon. Member for Brentwood and Ongar (Alex Burghart), who said...
Many people ask me—and, I dare say, every Member of Parliament—“Why on earth would you go into po...
Since I came into the House in 2001 I have seen a significant increase in the number of Members a...
I rise to speak because I believe this Government are the right Government to carry on with their...
The famous phrase is that a fish rots from the head down. It is a recognition that bad leadership...
I rise to speak on the behalf of not just Brenda from Bristol, but all the Brendas in Bexhill and...
I have no confidence in this Government and I have never have. I have no confidence because of ho...
I am sure that at some point in your life, Mr Speaker, it is possible that you have owned a copy ...
Some Conservative Members have been calling into question the motivations of the Opposition in ca...
There are moments in this Chamber for political knockabout, for consensus and for constructive de...
I rise in support of the Leader of the Opposition’s motion. As a teacher and headteacher througho...
When I was elected, my constituents in Stoke-on-Trent South were clear: they voted overwhelmingly...
Order. I know the House is excited, but the hon. Gentleman must get a respectful hearing.
Thank you, Mr Speaker.
We must continue to pursue measures that will help to address the co...
When I think of the confidence that I have in this Government, I think about how they have treate...
Does my hon. Friend agree that, in Scotland, people will be watching this thinking it is an absol...
Absolutely. We need a general election because there is no way to clear this impasse. There is a ...
I will try to keep my contribution very short. I rise tonight in support of the Government, mainl...
This has been a very passionately argued debate. At my count, 59 Members gave speeches, and they ...
As you know, Mr Speaker, having sat throughout this entire debate, it has been a passionate debat...
On a point of order, Mr Speaker.
I hope it is a genuine point of order.
The motion is about the Government. How is this relevant? Is this not dangerous?
If the Secretary of State were out of order, I would have said so. I did not because he is not.
Thank you very much, Mr Speaker.
If the Leader of the Opposition will not stand up against ...
On a point of order, Mr Speaker. I am pleased that the House has expressed its confidence in the ...
I call Jeremy Corbyn.
On a point of order, Mr Speaker. Last night the House rejected the Government’s conclusion of its...
Order. I called the Prime Minister on a point of order, and the Prime Minister was heard. She was...
Thank you, Mr Speaker.
Last night the House rejected the Government’s deal emphatically. A ...
On a point of order, Mr Speaker. I must say that I welcome the offer of talks from the Prime Mini...
On a point of order, Mr Speaker. From the Liberal Democrats position, we are clear that we want t...
On a point of order, Mr Speaker. The result of the motion of no confidence tonight illustrates th...
Order. Mr Stone, that is very unseemly behaviour. Normally you behave with great dignity in this ...
May I say, however, that the confidence and supply arrangement is of course built upon delivering...
If the right hon. Gentleman really feels he must make a point of order then he may, although he h...
On a point of order, Mr Speaker. I thank the Prime Minister for her assurance that the motion tha...
My response to the right hon. Gentleman, apart from thanking him for his point of order, is to sa...