Political Parties and Elections Bill

May I first support the Secretary of State's kind words about Lord Kingsland, who was a truly fine gentleman? He was caring, charming and a good lawyer; he was always fair in debate and rational in his approach. I have always enjoyed working with Lord Kingsland, who will be sadly missed by colleagues. Our thoughts are with his family. We can see the outline purpose of the Government amendments on clause 8's permissible-donor provisions, but the fact remains that the clause will be extremely hard to implement. We feel that it could be unreasonable to impose requirements that are so difficult to meet, particularly when the consequences are so draconian. It may be an infringement of an individual's right to freedom of expression; it is most likely to be contrary to European law; it would contribute to the isolation of UK citizens living abroad; it is contrary to regulatory principles; and it links political rights to taxation. Furthermore, it does not correctly address a mischief that the Political Parties, Elections and Referendums Act 2000 aimed to address—namely, a clarification of the rules on party donations. The Electoral Commission was concerned that those it regulates will not be able to comply with these proposals in their current form and that the resulting law will likely be unenforceable in practice. It has called on the Government to review clause 8, so the Minister might wish to report on the Commission's view in his reply. The change of Government policy over the past few days and the provision of these amendments only today are simply unacceptable. As my right hon. Friend the Member for Horsham (Mr. Maude) said, is it not true that only last Monday the Secretary of State told Labour Back Benchers that the Government proposed to impose a three-line Whip today to overturn these provisions? The Secretary of State said that that was not quite the case, but he did not answer my right hon. Friend's question about what had happened in the meantime. This is legislating on the hoof, and we do not much like it.