Data Retention (EC Directive) Regulations 2007

My Lords, I also thank the Minister for a very clear explanation of the regulations. We will not oppose them either, as they seem a sensible extension of our current arrangements. It would be useful to ask the Minister a few questions relating to the voice over internet protocol. Internet telephonic providers already have a competitive advantage. Will that continue to exist or will almost all internet providers be covered by this regulation? I am particularly keen to find out what other countries are doing in relation to what we are doing in this country. Are they, more or less, taking the same view on the practicalities? Has any other member state chosen to introduce the recycling directive, as I believe it is known, as it applies to internet telephony at an earlier date? What is the Minister’s understanding of why some countries want the provisions to be mandatory and not optional? The Information Commissioner plays a role in policing access arrangements as far as the British Government are concerned. Will he have a similar role when the information is derived from overseas providers? Given that we are now talking about a Europe-wide system, will the Information Commissioner’s remit run to any call that originates or ends in the United Kingdom? That would seem necessary for our protection. Has the Minister yet discussed that issue with his counterparts in other member states and with the Commission? It would be helpful to have this information.